There is a long standing bubbe meise among publishers & printers that Adobe Illustrator can be used to edit PDF documents. Guess what folks - that is simply NOT TRUE! And I’d like to look at two aspects of this.
Aspect 1 - PDF as AI’s native format
The bubbe meise may have come about due to a common misunderstanding about the “native file format” for Illustrator (since version 9). Even though the file extension is .ai, the file is, in reality, a 100% valid PDF document. Just change the extension and open in Reader - no problems!
However, even though this is true, Illustrator doesn’t actually use the “PDF parts” - it just uses PDF as a very nice envelope for it’s own private data. This is accomplished through the use of the /PieceInfo key on the /Page dictionary as documented in Section 10.4 of the PDF Reference. The actual Illustrator internal data is organized into the /Private key of /PieceInfo. Illustrator just reads this - ignoring the rest of the PDF. Photoshop also does the same thing with its “Photoshop PDF” format. This is why programs like PitStop, when you attempt to edit Illustrator or Photoshop documents, present a warning.
Aspect 2 - Illustrator’s ability to read/process & write PDFs
For many years, Illustrator has had the ability to open up PDFs and let you work with each “object” using the native AI toolbox - thus propogating the bubbe meise.
Although Illustrator CS2 supports most features of PDF, there are a variety of things that it is simply unable to handle correctly when opening. Fortunately, Illustrator will warn you about them - but most folks tend to ignore such warnings. Some (but not all) of the features not supported include:
- Multiple colorspaces (AI only supports a single colorspace on its canvas)
- All features of PDF transparency (groups & blending spaces, esp.)
- Certain complex smooth shadings
- Subset fonts using custom encodings
- Embedded fonts not installed on the editing computer (including Type 3 & TeX fonts)
In addition, any non-content elements such as bookmarks, hyperlinks, metadata, annotations, etc. will all be “thrown on the floor” by Illustrator. So keep that in mind as well.
BUT WAIT - there is some light at the end of the tunnel…
Adobe Acrobat (both Standard and Professional) include a tool called the Touchup Object Tool, that enables you to take an entire “object” and have it edited with an external editor. By default, the editors are Photoshop for raster data and Illustrator for vector & text. To use, just select the Touchup Object Tool (it’s connected to the Touchup Text Tools on the Advanced Editing Palette), hilite the object you wish to edit, right/control-click your mouse and choose “Edit Object…”. Off you go to your editor, make your corrections, then save - and the updates will appear back in Acrobat. Cool huh??
[This tip courtesy of Ted Padova]